Home insurance & natural hazards in Sullivan County, NY
Calm, plain facts for homeowners in Sullivan County: what neighbors have paid for coverage, what flood insurance costs, and which weather hazards matter most here.
- Typical premiums from U.S. Treasury insurance data
- Flood insurance costs from 338 FEMA NFIP policies
- 15 natural hazards rated by the FEMA National Risk Index
Historical averages, not a quote. Updated Oct 2026.
Sullivan at a glance
Four numbers most homeowners ask about first.
Per policy per year in 2022, median of 39 ZIP codes (inflation-adjusted).
Average full cost of a single-family NFIP policy that took effect in 2025.
Share of policies insurers chose not to renew in 2022, median ZIP. Typical U.S. ZIP: 0.81%.
Overall National Risk Index rating, higher than 78.3% of U.S. counties.
What homeowners here pay
Each block pairs a short explanation with the data behind it.
Homeowners insurance
Typical premiums in Sullivan County were $1,507 per policy in 2022, 24% above the typical New York ZIP code ($1,218) and about the same as the typical U.S. ZIP code ($1,551). After adjusting for inflation, local premiums rose 5% between 2018 and 2022.
Typical premium per policy
Flood insurance
Standard home policies don't cover floods. The average single-family NFIP policy that took effect here in 2025 cost $1,716, compared with $1,360 in 2022. About 55% of local policies are for homes in high-risk A or V zones and 45% in moderate- to lower-risk zones.
Average flood policy cost
Policies by flood zone, 2025
Natural hazards
Bars show how Sullivan compares with every U.S. county for each hazard (100 = highest). Inland flooding, hurricane and cold wave rank highest here. A high rank doesn't mean an event is likely in any given year. It shows where preparation and the right coverage matter most.
Hazard risk, national percentile
Compare nearby
Neighboring counties
| County | Premium | Nonrenewal | Flood |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sullivan County | $1,507 | 0.59% | $1,716 |
| Orange County | $1,493 | 0.38% | $1,333 |
| Ulster County | $1,487 | 0.35% | $1,747 |
| Pike County, PA | $1,343 | 0.49% | $1,418 |
| Wayne County, PA | $1,328 | 0.67% | $1,734 |
| Delaware County | $1,270 | 0.39% | $1,833 |
Flood insurance by ZIP, 2025
| ZIP | Policies | Avg. cost |
|---|---|---|
| 12758 Livingston Manor | 40 | $2,152 |
| 12764 Narrowsburg | 27 | $3,166 |
| 12701 Monticello | 23 | $1,255 |
| 12790 Wurtsboro | 21 | $1,347 |
| 12719 Barryville | 15 | $2,096 |
| 12723 Callicoon | 14 | $1,520 |
| 12748 Jeffersonville | 14 | $1,887 |
ZIP code pages in Sullivan County
Practical next steps
Simple things Sullivan homeowners can do with this information.
Historical averages, not a quote. Homeowners figures are inflation-adjusted averages from the U.S. Treasury Federal Insurance Office "Supporting Underlying Metrics" (2018–2022, published January 2025). They cover HO-3/HO-5 policies from participating private insurers and exclude state residual-market plans (such as FAIR plans and Citizens), surplus-lines and flood coverage. Treasury notes that individual ZIP codes can contain data anomalies. Your price depends on your home, coverage and insurer.
Sources: U.S. Treasury FIO; FEMA OpenFEMA NFIP Redacted Policies v3 (data as of Sep 8, 2026); FEMA National Risk Index (December 2025); U.S. Census Bureau ZCTA-to-county relationship file (2020) and county adjacency file; GeoNames place names. How we calculate these numbers.
This product uses the FEMA OpenFEMA API and National Risk Index data, but is not endorsed by FEMA. The Federal Government or FEMA cannot vouch for the data or analyses derived from these data after the data have been retrieved from the Agency's website(s). SafeHomeFacts is independent and not affiliated with the U.S. Treasury, FEMA or any insurer.